TRENDEFRARAtlas of the Sultans · Myths and misconceptions
Misconception · No: the practice was older; Mehmed II turned it into a written provision of his law code (kanunname).
Open the map in 1389It is often said that the Ottoman practice of a new sultan having his brothers killed began with the clause “for the order of the world” in the law code (kanunname) of Mehmed II, the Conqueror. The belief arises because the best-known and most explicit written statement of the practice does indeed belong to Mehmed II. The sources, however, show that rather than starting something new, he put into writing a practice seen since the earliest days of the Ottoman principality.
According to the article “Şehzade” in the TDV Encyclopedia of Islam, killings within the dynasty began in the founding years with Osman Bey's killing of his uncle Dündar and continued with Bayezid I having his brother Yakub strangled. Citing the poet and chronicler Ahmedi, the article “Cülus” also reports that Murad I had his brothers Ibrahim and Halil killed when they moved to claim the throne. Bayezid I came to the throne in 1389 on the death of his father Murad I at the Battle of Kosovo; according to the article on Bayezid I, he had his only surviving brother Yakub killed on the advice of the state dignitaries so that he would not cause a civil war. The article “Cülus” regards this as the first killing carried out without waiting for a revolt, unlike earlier killings of those who had rebelled against a legitimate ruler.
Later struggles for the throne also ended in bloodshed. After the defeat at Ankara (1402), Mehmed I reached the throne by eliminating his brothers; his brother Musa Çelebi, for example, was strangled by Mehmed's men in 1413. Murad II had first his uncle, known as Düzmece (“False”) Mustafa, and then his rebellious brother Mustafa Çelebi killed. Mehmed II himself, as soon as he took the throne in 1451, had his infant brother Ahmed strangled.
Mehmed II's contribution was to turn this practice into a written rule. In the law code in which he compiled the rules of state organisation and ceremony, he set out no order of succession and wrote only: “To whichever of my sons the sultanate is granted, it is appropriate that he kill his brothers for the order of the world. Most of the ulema have also approved it.” In other words, he considered it proper for the son who took the throne to have his brothers killed to preserve order (nizam-ı alem), noting that most religious scholars agreed. The article “Osmanlılar” likewise states that fratricide, “which had been practised before”, found its place in the Law Code of Mehmed II. Later sultans continued the practice: Selim I extended it to his brothers' sons, and Mehmed III had nineteen brothers killed on his accession in 1595. Ahmed I was the first sultan not to follow this law.
The law code of Mehmed II is the best-known text that names fratricide openly and gives a reason for it, so it is remembered as the origin of the practice. In the article “Kanunname”, Halil Inalcık notes that Mehmed II's code on state organisation is unique of its kind and that later regulations were not as comprehensive. Such a prominent text has overshadowed the scattered earlier cases.
In addition, most earlier killings took place during a rebellion or a struggle for the throne, so they are remembered as individual events rather than as a “law”. The article “Şehzade” points out that the method was not unique to the Ottomans and that its basic purpose was to protect the ruler's sovereignty and absolute authority; in the article on Mehmed II, Halil Inalcık writes that the sultan intended this provision to secure the indivisibility of sovereignty.
Fratricide did not begin with Mehmed II: cases such as Bayezid I having his brother Yakub killed in 1389 are much older. What Mehmed II did was give the practice a written basis in his law code, justified “for the order of the world”. The practice began to be abandoned in the early 17th century, under Ahmed I, giving way to the principle of ekberiyet, succession by the oldest member of the dynasty.
Cite as: Atlas of the Sultans, “Did fratricide begin with Mehmed the Conqueror's law code? · Myths and misconceptions”, https://padisahlaratlasi.com/en/ottoman-history-myths/did-fratricide-begin-with-mehmed-the-conqueror-s-law-code/ (last updated 21 November 2026). Corrections · Image credits