TRENDEFRARAtlas of the Sultans · Myths and misconceptions
Misconception · No: contemporary sources record no such ceremony; the story first appears in d'Ohsson in the late 18th century.
Open the map in 1517It is widely told that after Selim I (Yavuz) destroyed the Mamluk Sultanate and took Egypt in 1517, he received the caliphate from the last Abbasid caliph, al-Mutawakkil III, in a formal ceremony. In some versions the ceremony takes place in Cairo; in others, in Istanbul, at the Eyüp Mosque or Hagia Sophia, where the caliph girds the sultan with the sword of the caliphate. According to this view, the Ottoman sultans first acquired the title of caliph through this ceremony.
According to the article on Selim I in the TDV Encyclopedia of Islam, the Abbasid caliph al-Mutawakkil, who accompanied the Mamluk sultan, fell into Ottoman hands after the Battle of Marj Dabiq (24 August 1516); Selim treated him with great respect and met him at Gökmeydan in Aleppo. After the victory at Ridaniya (22 January 1517) the sultan entered Cairo, and on his way back from Egypt he sent the caliph and his relatives to Istanbul by sea, together with scholars and craftsmen. In the same article, however, Feridun Emecen writes that the reports of Selim taking over the caliphate and bequeathing it to his descendants are doubtful, and that the story of his receiving it from the caliph in a ceremony at Hagia Sophia in Istanbul “has no historical value”.
In the Ottoman section of the article “Hilafet” (caliphate), Azmi Özcan makes the same point: whereas later sources describe the ceremony, the sources of Selim's own time contain no record of it; apart from a phrase in Hoca Sadeddin Efendi saying that Selim had rightfully put on “the robe of the caliphate”, nothing is found. The first account of the ceremony appears in d'Ohsson's Tableau général de l'Empire othoman, written towards the end of the 18th century. Modern historians argue that, since no original source documents such a ceremony, the later reports are fabricated and that the Ottomans projected them back into the past at times when they needed the spiritual authority of the caliphate.
This does not mean that the Ottoman sultans did not use the title of caliph. According to the article “Hilafet”, Ottoman sultans had used it in their correspondence since Murad I. With the conquest of Egypt and the Hijaz, Selim took the title “hadimü'l-Haremeyni'ş-şerifeyn”, and official documents refer to him as protector of Mecca and Medina; Suleiman the Magnificent wrote in his letters that God had raised him to “the throne of the sultanate and the caliphate”. The article also stresses that Islamic law required no ceremony for the transfer of the caliphate and that the tradition of the institution knew no formal handover ceremony.
According to the article “Hilafet”, the 1774 Treaty of Küçük Kaynarca is generally regarded as a turning point in the Ottomans' growing emphasis on the caliphate: it is the first official document showing a Western state recognising the Ottoman sultan as caliph of all Muslims. In the view of modern historians, the story of a ceremonial handover to Selim was told retrospectively in such periods, when the spiritual authority of the caliphate mattered more in politics, and later writers repeated it.
The debate is also confused because two separate questions are often mixed up: whether a handover ceremony took place, and whether the Ottoman caliphate was legitimate. The article “Hilafet” notes that the lack of evidence for a ceremony does not invalidate the Ottoman caliphate; Islamic jurists focused rather on the fact that the Ottoman sultans did not descend from the Quraysh, a question first addressed under Süleyman by the grand vizier Lutfi Pasha.
The sources of the period contain no record that al-Mutawakkil handed the caliphate to Selim in a ceremony in Cairo or Istanbul in 1517; the story first appears in the late 18th century. The Ottoman sultans had already used the title of caliph, and the conquest of Egypt and the Hijaz gave it new weight.
Source: TDV Encyclopedia of Islam, “HİLÂFET” (Azmi Özcan); also “SELİM I” (Feridun Emecen)
Cite as: Atlas of the Sultans, “Was the caliphate handed over to Selim I in a ceremony in Egypt in 1517? · Myths and misconceptions”, https://padisahlaratlasi.com/en/ottoman-history-myths/was-the-caliphate-handed-over-to-selim-i-in-a-ceremony-in-egypt-in-1517/ (last updated 21 November 2026). Corrections · Image credits