TRENDEFRARAtlas of the Sultans · Myths and misconceptions
Misconception · Partly: until 1617 the eldest son usually succeeded, by custom, not rule; then the dynasty's eldest member did.
Open the map in 1617It is often assumed that the Ottoman throne always passed to the sultan's eldest son, in other words from father to firstborn. The impression comes largely from the first three centuries, when most rulers really were the eldest surviving son. Yet this pattern rested on no written rule, and it changed completely after 1617: from then on the throne went not to the sultan's son but to the oldest male member of the dynasty.
According to the article “Şehzade” (prince) in the TDV Encyclopedia of Islam, of the thirteen rulers who took the throne in the roughly three centuries from Orhan Bey to the accession of Ahmed I, eleven did so as the eldest surviving son; the exceptions were Mehmed I and Selim I (Yavuz). The article concludes that the eldest son with the qualities needed to rule was regarded as heir by a custom that was “not official”. The article “Cülus” (accession) likewise says that the throne passed to the eldest prince “with a few exceptions”, while the article on Ahmed I stresses that until then accession followed no fixed rule.
The change came in 1617. When Ahmed I died young, his brother Mustafa was enthroned on 22 November 1617, although Ahmed's eldest son Osman was alive. According to the article on Mustafa I, the decision was brought about by the şeyhülislam (the chief religious authority) Hocazade Esad Efendi, who won over the grand vizier's deputy Sofu Mehmed Pasha and other dignitaries; the contemporary historian Mehmed b. Mehmed Edirnevi criticised it, writing that in the Ottoman succession system the throne belonged to the son, not the brother. The sources also mention the influence of the Chief Black Eunuch Mustafa Agha and of Kösem Sultan. Mustafa I, known to be mentally unstable, was deposed about three months later, on 26 February 1618, and replaced by Ahmed I's fifteen-year-old eldest son, Osman II.
Osman II objected to the new practice, declaring that the throne was his by “kanun-ı kadim” (ancient law). Nevertheless, according to the article “Cülus”, later accessions always followed the principle of “ekberiyet” and “erşediyet”, meaning that the eldest member of the dynasty took the throne, while the other princes lived under supervision in a closed part of the palace known as the “kafes” (cage). The principle was even written into Article 3 of the Ottoman constitution of 1876 (Kanun-ı Esasi): the sultanate belonged, “according to ancient custom”, to the eldest of the House of Osman.
The belief reflects a real tendency: most rulers of the first three centuries were indeed eldest sons. But this depended on circumstances, not on law. According to the article on Mehmed I, in the prevailing Turkic tradition every son of a ruler had the right to succeed his father and no law regulated succession. This is why Bayezid I's sons fought one another for the throne after 1402, and why Mehmed I, who was not the eldest, became sultan by winning that struggle. Selim I likewise seized the throne with the support of the janissaries, although his father Bayezid II favoured his eldest son Ahmed.
The practice after 1617 is often overlooked as well. Under the new order, the new sultan could be the previous ruler's brother or nephew rather than his son; Ahmed III, for example, handed the throne to his nephew Mahmud, the oldest member of the dynasty. The article “Cülus” also emphasises the large role that palace officials and the valide sultans (the sultans' mothers) played in these accessions.
Succession by the eldest son was not a written rule in the Ottoman state but a custom that lasted about three centuries and had two notable exceptions. It ended in 1617, when Ahmed I was followed by his brother Mustafa I; afterwards the principle of “ekberiyet”, succession by the oldest male of the dynasty, became established and was later written into the constitution of 1876.
Cite as: Atlas of the Sultans, “Did the eldest son always inherit the Ottoman throne? · Myths and misconceptions”, https://padisahlaratlasi.com/en/ottoman-history-myths/did-the-eldest-son-always-inherit-the-ottoman-throne/ (last updated 21 November 2026). Corrections · Image credits