Map Map Sultans and State Sultans Events and Culture Events Learn and Play Learn
TR EN DE FRع ARAtlas of the Sultans
Myths and Misconceptions in Ottoman History: Sourced Answers
Some often-repeated statements about Ottoman history are wrong, incomplete or oversimplified. Each page takes one common belief as a question and explains, on the basis of the TDV Encyclopedia of Islam, what the sources actually say and where the misconception comes from. In some cases the answer is not “false” but “partly true” or “disputed”, and we say so plainly.
Was the Ottoman state founded in 1299? Partly: 1299 is the traditional date; the TDV sees the Bapheus victory of 27 July 1302 as a firmer start. Was Istanbul always the Ottoman capital? No: Istanbul became the capital in 1453; before that Bursa and Edirne, and first Söğüt and Bilecik, were the centres. Did the Ottomans reach their greatest extent under Suleiman the Magnificent? Not by the atlas's measure: the largest extent came in 1590–1596, under Murad III and Mehmed III (~5.25 million km²). Were Crimea, Wallachia and Moldavia Ottoman territory? Partly: all three were bound to the Ottomans but were tributary states ruled by their own princes. Did the eldest son always inherit the Ottoman throne? Partly: until 1617 the eldest son usually succeeded, by custom, not rule; then the dynasty's eldest member did. Did fratricide begin with Mehmed the Conqueror's law code? No: the practice was older; Mehmed II turned it into a written provision of his law code (kanunname). Was the caliphate handed over to Selim I in a ceremony in Egypt in 1517? No: contemporary sources record no such ceremony; the story first appears in d'Ohsson in the late 18th century. Was the Tulip Era called by that name in its own time? No: the name does not appear in the period's chronicles; it was first used by Yahya Kemal in the early 20th century. Did women really rule the state during the “Sultanate of Women”? Partly: valide sultans were very influential in 1574–1656, but they did not govern the state on their own. Was the tughra the sultan's own handwritten signature? No: the tughra served in place of a signature, but it was usually drawn by an official, the nişancı, not the sultan. Did the sultan preside over meetings of the Imperial Council (Divan-ı Hümayun)? Sometimes before Mehmed II; after him the grand vizier presided, and the sultan could listen from behind a grille. Was the Ottoman army made up mostly of Janissaries? No: in the classical period the army's main force was the timariot cavalry; the Janissaries were an elite but small central corps. Did the devshirme take every Christian child? No: the devshirme was a rule-bound selection limited by age, family situation, region and community. Did the Ottoman state collapse right after the 1683 defeat at Vienna? No: the losses of 1683–1699 were heavy, but some lands were regained in 1711–1739; the state lasted until 1922. When did the Ottoman state end: 1922, 1923 or 1924? The sultanate was abolished on 1 November 1922; Lausanne, the Republic (1923) and the end of the caliphate (1924) completed it.
Grand viziers Ottoman monuments Women of the dynasty Ottoman capitals State organisation Back to the map