TRENDEFRARAtlas of the Sultans · Myths and misconceptions
Misconception · Partly: all three were bound to the Ottomans but were tributary states ruled by their own princes.
Open the map in 1395On Ottoman maps, Crimea, Wallachia (Eflak, today's southern Romania) and Moldavia (Boğdan, today's Moldova and north-eastern Romania) are often painted the same colour as Anatolia and Rumelia. It is therefore assumed that these lands, too, were governed like Ottoman provinces, by governors-general (beylerbeyi) and district governors (sancak beyi) appointed from Istanbul.
The Crimean Khanate (1441–1783) was a state that emerged during the break-up of the Golden Horde. According to the “Kırım” (Crimea) entry of the TDV Encyclopedia of Islam, in 1475 the Ottomans took Kaffa (Kefe) and the former Genoese colonies on the coast and formed a district (sancak) there; the coast from Kerch to Balaklava came under direct Ottoman control, while the interior belonged to the Crimean khans. According to the section written by Halil Inalcık, Mengli Giray accepted the sultan's suzerainty that same year; contrary to a common claim, however, there is no document of vassalage: the khan agreed to be a friend to the sultan's friends and an enemy to his enemies and accepted his protection. In time khans could be sent from Istanbul; Islam Giray II began to have the sultan's name read in the Friday sermon as well, but coins were always struck in the name of the Girays.
Wallachia and Moldavia, too, were Christian principalities ruled by their own voivodes (princes). According to the “Boğdan” entry (Abdülkadir Özcan), the Ottomans first made Wallachia pay tribute under Mehmed I (1413–1421), while Moldavia became tributary after the conquest of Istanbul, from 1455. Mehmed II did not interfere in the principality's internal affairs and did not turn Moldavia into a province governed by an Ottoman pasha. According to the “Eflak” entry (Kemal Karpat), Wallachia continued through the 17th century to be ruled by native dynasties as an Ottoman tributary; between 1716 and 1821, however, Phanariot Greek families of Istanbul were appointed as voivodes.
Some strategic places within or along these lands were, however, directly Ottoman: the district of Kaffa in Crimea; Kilia and Akkerman (1484) on the Moldavian coast; Bender and the Budjak (southern Bessarabia), annexed to Ottoman lands after Suleiman's campaign of 1538; and for a time Wallachia's Danube ports of Brăila and Giurgiu. Nor did vassalage last forever: the Treaty of Küçük Kaynarca (21 July 1774) declared Crimea independent, and Russia annexed the peninsula in 1783. Wallachia and Moldavia united under the name Romania after electing Alexandru Ioan Cuza as their common prince in 1859, and declared independence during the Russo-Ottoman War of 1877–1878.
The main reason for the confusion is that Ottoman sovereignty was not uniform. On one side were provinces run by judges (kadı) and district governors and recorded in land-survey registers (tahrir defterleri); on the other were dependent states that paid tribute or supplied troops but had their own rulers, laws and church. The Crimean khans joined Ottoman campaigns, and Wallachian troops served in the Ottoman army on Mehmed II's Moldavian campaign; this close relationship makes it easy to overlook the difference between “bound to the Ottomans” and “ruled by the Ottomans”.
The Padişahlar Atlası shows this difference with a single criterion: states ruled by their own princes that paid tribute to the Ottomans or supplied troops are not counted in the territorial area; on the map they appear in a separate layer, in light green with dashed edges. According to the atlas, Wallachia was tributary in 1395–1402 and 1413–1877, Moldavia in 1455–1877, and the Crimean Khanate, together with the Kuban and Anapa coast, in 1475–1774. The directly Ottoman territory in Crimea is removed from the area in 1771, when the Russian occupation that was never reversed began. By contrast, Algiers, Tunis and Tripoli, governed as beylerbeyiliks (provinces), are counted because they were provinces.
Crimea, Wallachia and Moldavia were bound to the Ottomans for centuries: they paid tribute, sent troops on campaigns, and their rulers often took the throne with Istanbul's approval. But they were tributary states ruled by their own princes; the directly Ottoman places were certain coastal and fortress areas such as Kaffa, Akkerman, Kilia and Bender.
Cite as: Atlas of the Sultans, “Were Crimea, Wallachia and Moldavia Ottoman territory? · Myths and misconceptions”, https://padisahlaratlasi.com/en/ottoman-history-myths/were-crimea-wallachia-and-moldavia-ottoman-territory/ (last updated 21 November 2026). Corrections · Image credits