TRENDEFRARAtlas of the Sultans · Myths and misconceptions
Misconception · Sometimes before Mehmed II; after him the grand vizier presided, and the sultan could listen from behind a grille.
Open the map in 1451The Imperial Council (Divan-ı Hümayun) calls to mind, for most people, a meeting in which the sultan sits in the place of honour and personally discusses affairs of state with his viziers. The word “hümayun” in its name supports this idea, since it means “belonging to the sultan”. It is therefore assumed that the sultan was the council's natural chairman.
According to Ahmet Mumcu's article “Dîvân-ı Hümâyun” in the TDV Encyclopedia of Islam, the name does indeed mean “the sultan's council”, and the council took decisions in the sultan's name. The early Ottoman principality also had a simple council, but because reliable sources are lacking until the mid-15th century, its development is hard to trace. What is known is that under Murad II the council meeting in Edirne began to take on the character of the Divan-ı Hümayun, and that the sultan sometimes presided over it.
The change came with Mehmed II, the Conqueror. Mumcu writes that the law code (kanunname) attributed to Mehmed II also regulated the council, and that its greatest innovation was to abolish definitively the sultan's chairmanship of the council and leave this role to the grand vizier. Mehmet Ipşirli's article “Sadrazam” likewise defines the Divan-ı Hümayun as the most important council meeting under the chairmanship of the grand vizier, even though its name means “the sultan's council”; when the grand vizier went on campaign, the council was convened and chaired by his deputy left in the capital, the sadaret kaymakamı. According to Halil Inalcık's article “Mehmed II”, the Conqueror increased the powers of grand viziers “in their capacity as his deputies”, making them the representatives of his centralised government. The council's full members were the grand vizier, the dome viziers (usually between three and seven), the chief judges (kazasker) of Rumelia and Anatolia, the nişancı and the treasurers (defterdar); the şeyhülislam was not a member.
The sultan was nonetheless not entirely removed from the process. Meetings were held wherever the sultan resided, in Istanbul in the Kubbealtı (Dome Chamber) in the second courtyard of Topkapı Palace, adjoining the Harem. According to Mumcu, the sultan could listen to the proceedings whenever he wished from behind a latticed window opening onto the chamber. Some matters were not finalised until they had been submitted to the sultan, a procedure called “arza çıkmak” (going to audience): after the meeting the members went before the sultan in turn to report, and decisions became final once he approved them. According to Ipşirli, from the reign of Murad III onwards face-to-face audiences declined, and it became common to send the sultan written summaries (telhis) and for him to reply with a hatt-ı hümayun (a note in his own hand). In the 16th century the council met four or five days a week, starting after the dawn prayer and normally lasting until the noon call to prayer; its agenda was prepared by the reisülküttap (chief scribe).
The belief has some basis: the council's name means “the sultan's council”, meetings took place in the sultan's palace, decisions were taken in his name and decrees were issued under his tughra. It is also true that before Mehmed II the sultan sometimes presided over the council. This is why “the sultan's council” and “the council chaired by the sultan” are easily confused.
The council's later history complicates the picture further. According to Mumcu, the Divan-ı Hümayun, which from the early 16th to the late 17th century held the most important place in the state after the sultan, gradually lost its powers to the grand vizier's afternoon council (ikindi divanı); by the mid-18th century, with the growth of the Bab-ı Asafi (the grand vizier's office), it had become a place of ceremony, and with the reforms of Mahmud II it gave way to a cabinet system, though it was preserved as an instrument of protocol until the end of the state. Describing an institution that changed over centuries with a single image leads to the sultan's role being remembered differently from what it was.
Before Mehmed II, especially under Murad II, the sultan is known to have presided over the council at times. With Mehmed II's law code this chairmanship was left to the grand vizier; the sultan could listen to the meetings from behind a latticed window, while important decisions were submitted for his approval through the “arz”.
Source: TDV Encyclopedia of Islam, “DÎVÂN-ı HÜMÂYUN” (Ahmet Mumcu)
Cite as: Atlas of the Sultans, “Did the sultan preside over meetings of the Imperial Council (Divan-ı Hümayun)? · Myths and misconceptions”, https://padisahlaratlasi.com/en/ottoman-history-myths/did-the-sultan-preside-over-meetings-of-the-imperial-council-divan-i-humayun/ (last updated 21 November 2026). Corrections · Image credits